Paper stamp cards or digital: what changes for a cafe
Paper stamp cards have worked in cafes for a long time, and for plenty of cafes they still do. If you're thinking about going digital, it's worth being clear about what you'd gain, what you'd give up, and what stays the same.
Hello Regulars is a digital loyalty product, and it's ours. We've tried to be fair to paper anyway, because it has real strengths.
What paper does well
It's cheap. A print run of cards and a rubber stamp is about all it takes. There's no monthly fee, no contract, and nothing to cancel.
There's no tech. There's nothing to set up, no login, no iPad to charge, and nothing that stops working when the internet drops. A new staff member understands it straight away.
Everyone gets it. Customers know how a stamp card works without being told. Nobody needs a smartphone, an email address, or an app.
It's in their wallet. A card with seven stamps on it is a small reminder every time they open their wallet.
If your regulars are happy and your cards rarely go missing, paper may be all you need.
Where paper falls short
Cards get lost and forgotten. A regular leaves their card at home, so you start them a new one. A month later they have three half-full cards, or they've given up. Every lost card is stamps they earned and won't redeem, and to them it can feel like the cafe kept something.
Cards are easy to fake. A stamp that looks like yours isn't hard to find, and an extra stamp from a generous staff member is impossible to spot. Most regulars would never do it, but you can't tell when someone has.
You don't know who your regulars are. A paper card leaves the cafe in the customer's pocket. You can't see how many regulars you have, how often they come, or who hasn't been in for a month. You can't tell a regular their free coffee is waiting, and you can't thank the ones who come in every day.
There's no record. If a regular says they had nine stamps, not eight, there's nothing to check.
What changes when you go digital
Every digital loyalty program moves the card from the customer's pocket to a record the cafe keeps. That one change is behind most of the differences.
The card can't be lost or faked. Every stamp is recorded, usually with the day and time it was added, so there's no double stamping and nothing to forge.
You need a way to find the customer. This is the biggest difference between products. Some ask the customer to open an app or show a code. Some use the customer's mobile number, so staff type a few digits. Some let staff find a customer by name. Which suits you depends on your regulars. If many of them don't carry a smartphone or won't download an app, an app-based card leaves them out.
You learn who your regulars are. You can see how many regulars you have, how often they visit, and when you're busy or quiet. Some products also show what sells.
You can tell them when their reward is ready. Most digital programs can send a text, an email, or a push notification. In Australia, marketing texts need the customer's consent under the Spam Act, and every message must say who it's from and make it easy to unsubscribe (ACMA: Avoid sending spam). Look for a product that asks the question at the counter and keeps a record of the answer.
It costs money every month. Digital programs charge a monthly fee, and some charge per location or per text. We've collected the published prices in what a cafe loyalty program costs.
There's a little to learn. Staff need a few minutes of training, and you need a device at the counter. Many products run on an iPad or phone you already have.
What doesn't change
The rewards are still the main cost. A free coffee costs you the same whether it was earned on paper or on a screen.
The relationship is still yours. A loyalty card doesn't make someone a regular. Good coffee, a friendly hello, and remembering their order still do that. A digital card just means you don't lose track of who they are.
Moving from paper without losing anyone
If you switch, the thing your regulars will care about most is their stamps. A few things help.
- Pick a day. Tell regulars that from that day, the card moves to digital and their paper stamps come with them.
- Carry the stamps across. When a regular brings in their paper card, add those stamps to their new card. In Hello Regulars, staff enter them on the same screen when the regular joins (carry over stamps from a paper card).
- Keep the paper card. Take it once the stamps are across, so it can't be used twice.
- Don't chase anyone. Regulars who forget their card can bring it next time, and their stamps come across then.
- Put up a sign. A sign at the counter that says "Just give us your mobile number or name" saves staff explaining it all day (print your counter sign).
So, paper or digital?
Stay with paper if your cards rarely go missing, you don't mind not knowing who your regulars are, and you'd rather not pay a monthly fee.
Go digital if lost cards and double stamping are a regular annoyance, you'd like to know who your regulars are, or you'd like to tell them when their reward is ready.
If you go digital, choose something your regulars will actually use. If some of them don't do apps, look for a program where the card is their mobile number or name. That's how Hello Regulars works: loyalty without an app. For more to ask before you choose, see 9 questions to ask any loyalty provider.